Ah, Vista Launch Day, here at last. Microsoft assures me that “The Wow Starts Now,” but I am unconvinced, and I’m not the only one. Engadget on reviews of Windows Vista: “The overall verdict right now seems quite lacking in enthusiasm.” I’ll say. Summary:
…Things are much easier to use in general, but inconsistencies are often jarring, and certain added features don't seem entirely fleshed out, making the OS -- which was five years in development -- feel rushed and in noticeable need of that SP1 update. There's also a penchant for preferential treatment of Microsoft stuff, such as IE RSS feeds, which some Mac users might find disappointingly familiar. On the numbers side of things, bit-tech has discovered a 10 percent performance hit in most operations in comparison to XP, which isn't noticeable on high-end PCs, but might be enough of a reason for low-end users to hold off for the moment. …the number of different versions is way too confusing, and the full versions of the OS are too expensive. Most still agree that Vista is the best version of Windows yet, but it looks like you'll still have to figure out if it's the best for you.
And let’s not forget Mike Elgan’s take for Computerworld: Wait! Don't Buy Microsoft Windows Vista.
Again, count me among those who don’t buy that Vista is the best version of Windows. It absolutely could have been, and I had high hopes going into the beta. But Microsoft dropped the ball here, and I doubt even the already-announced Vista Service Pack 1, they’ll have changed enough to win me over. Vista offers too few benefits over Windows XP for the time I had to wait and the money they expect me to pay, and there are enough incomplete, ill-conceived, or downright anti-user changes that they offset the appeal of those limited benefits.
In a way, I would like to see Microsoft burned badly by Vista, not out of malice, but because it might shock them into radically rethinking where they are going, and heading instead in a direction I want to follow. I don’t have a lot of hope that will happen. I suspect Vista will do well enough, because it will ship on most new PCs, and most users either won’t care about Vista’s shortcomings or won’t know enough to ask for XP instead. Microsoft will keep going wherever they’re going, and I’ll be left here wondering where that is, exactly.
Microsoft has accomplished one thing with Vista that impresses me: after years of roundly mocking my Mac-loving friends, I’m actually considering joining them. XP works fine for me, but I so thrive on novelty that I really want a great, shiny new OS, and waiting for Microsoft to provide it has left me nothing but disappointed. Mac OS Leopard, XP, and Boot Camp or Parallels may just be my next upgrade.
Recent Comments